AI Peer Review

Better reviews, better science. Calibrated, citation-grounded reviews with humans in the loop, kept yours to edit, share, and publish.

Get your first reviewSee example reviewPurpose statementPublicationData policyRun a pilot

In this work, we model the risk of hospitalization for a large number of drug-disease combinations. Our methodology is akin to genome-wide association studies (GWAS), in which a simple model is used to estimate the effect of a large number of loci in a hypothesis-free manner. As in GWAS, this screen risks spurious relationships and requires further analysis, but complements target-driven repurposing.

observationIntroduction, p.2

The GWAS analogy is one of the clearest framings in the paper. It belongs in the abstract. A short sentence on the broad enumeration step and the multiplicity correction does enough to place the work as a screen, not another pair-specific observational study.

weaknessCox Regression, p.6

§2.5 and the Discussion already concede that dosage, duration, and switching aren't in the data. Even so, the paper keeps calling this a treatment-effect screen. Either tone the language down to a baseline-exposure association screen, or add landmark sensitivity analyses at 1, 3, 5, and 10 years.

Humans in the loop

Our reviews update with your comments. Iterate together until the review completely reflects your read.

EvaluateAnnotateRecommend

Consistent, benchmarked, multi-faceted scores

Publications are graded based on multiple aspects, including the novelty of the work, the quality of the presentation, and experimental rigor.

2,182 graded papers

066.2Median100

Research intelligence

We evaluate thousands of publications every week.
See our reports on

X Bluesky LinkedIn AIPR

See full map

Some of this week's best preprints

More on rankings

#	Paper	Score
1 RealDocBench: A Benchmark for Field-Level QA and Layout Understanding on Real-World Regulated Documents 82.2 Ameya Joshi et al.Computer Vision	1	RealDocBench: A Benchmark for Field-Level QA and Layout Understanding on Real-World Regulated Documents Ameya Joshi et al.Computer Vision	82.2
2 GitInject: Real-World Prompt Injection Attacks in AI-Powered CI/CD Pipelines 80.2 Jafar Isbarov et al.AI	2	GitInject: Real-World Prompt Injection Attacks in AI-Powered CI/CD Pipelines Jafar Isbarov et al.AI	80.2
3 vla.cpp: A Unified Inference Runtime for Vision-Language-Action Models 79.8 Khanh D. Nguyen et al.Robotics	3	vla.cpp: A Unified Inference Runtime for Vision-Language-Action Models Khanh D. Nguyen et al.Robotics	79.8
4 ScaleDisturb: Exploiting Temporal Asymmetry to Amplify Read Disturbance in Modern DRAM Chips 78.9 Jikun Wang et al.Computer Architecture	4	ScaleDisturb: Exploiting Temporal Asymmetry to Amplify Read Disturbance in Modern DRAM Chips Jikun Wang et al.Computer Architecture	78.9
5 The CIFAR Synthetic Evidence Corpus for Detecting AI-Generated Evidence 78.3 Kelly McConvey et al.AI	5	The CIFAR Synthetic Evidence Corpus for Detecting AI-Generated Evidence Kelly McConvey et al.AI	78.3
6 The Windows IOCTL Census: A Corpus-Scale, Multi-Architecture Database of the Driver Control-Code Surface 77.4 Michael J. Bommarito IIOperating Systems	6	The Windows IOCTL Census: A Corpus-Scale, Multi-Architecture Database of the Driver Control-Code Surface Michael J. Bommarito IIOperating Systems	77.4
7 Optimal Online Equitable Allocation with Indivisible Resources 77.1 Ramiro N. Deo-Campo VuongOptimization	7	Optimal Online Equitable Allocation with Indivisible Resources Ramiro N. Deo-Campo VuongOptimization	77.1
8 STAR-KV: Low-Rank KV Cache Compression via Soft Thresholding for Adaptive Rank Control 76.8 Priyansh Bhatnagar et al.Machine Learning	8	STAR-KV: Low-Rank KV Cache Compression via Soft Thresholding for Adaptive Rank Control Priyansh Bhatnagar et al.Machine Learning	76.8
9 Verifiable and Confidential DNN Inference on Low-End Edge Devices 76.5 Mohamed Khalil Kiri et al.Machine Learning	9	Verifiable and Confidential DNN Inference on Low-End Edge Devices Mohamed Khalil Kiri et al.Machine Learning	76.5
10 Gated Bidirectional Linear Attention for Generative Retrieval 76.1 Artem Matveev et al.Information Retrieval	10	Gated Bidirectional Linear Attention for Generative Retrieval Artem Matveev et al.Information Retrieval	76.1

Get your work graded

Your first review is free. Pay as you go or subscribe for additional features.

Create free account See plans Contact us